Pick of the Day

Something Tragic by Jessica Yeh

⭐⭐⭐⭐☆★ There are some books that hold you in a thrall of emotions that they create long after you’ve finished them. You have emotions...

The Wrong McElroy by K.L. Hughes

⭐⭐⭐☆

Fiona Ng is an out-and-proud lesbian. However, when her best friend Michael McElroy needs an arm candy to take home for Christmas so that his family gets off his back about his love life, Fiona somehow finds herself roped in as the ‘girlfriend’. Christmas at the McElroy’s is a family affair – except that the family huge. There are the parents, at least two sets of twins, a grandmother, two single sisters, some nieces and nephews and we are sure we’re forgetting some more. Once there, Fiona finds an unexpected issue – she is attracted to the wrong McElroy, Michael’s younger sister, Lizzie. Singleton Lizzie, confusingly seems to return Fiona’s attraction.

This book’s premise is exactly the same as Erica Lee’s Anyone but Her including similar plot points like:


  • BFFs of opposite genders
  • Big family shindig in the guy BFF’s near future
  • Lesbian BFF becomes fake girlfriend for the duration of the family reunion to get family off the guy’s back
  • Guy’s sister is closeted and family has no clue about said sister’s sexuality
  • Attraction between sister and brother's fake girlfriend
  • Sister vehemently defends brother's fake girlfriend during an early family interaction
  • Guy BFF also has alternative sexuality (gay in Erica Lee’s book and possibly asexual in this one)
  • Fake girlfriend-sister caught in a compromising position leading to the denouement which involves the whole family


Despite all the similarities, this is a hugely entertaining book because it is brilliantly funny. Fiona and the almost gothic baby sister of the family, Jessie are adorable. This is a romcom that aims to be more ‘com’ than ‘rom’ and succeeds. Interestingly, there is no real end or conclusion to the romance between the two MCs. Also, the whole sex scene between them was plain forced into the narrative. At the point it came, it was completely unnecessary and didn’t flow in the timeline at all in addition to being very, very poorly timed.

This is a good choice for something that gives you the giggles.

PS: All the stars here for the hugely entertaining writing.

Support this Site with a Donation

Search Review by Author or Book Name

#Trending

Search Review by Author or Book Name

Most Read This Week

Search Review By Author Or Book Name

Most Read in the Last 30 Days

Search Review by Author or Book Name